How to perform an LCA
An overall piece of advice is that you should spend enough time in the goal and scope
definition and the interpretation phases, and avoid overspending time in the
data inventory phase. Additionally, try to involve the result user and other
relevant stakeholders as actively as possible in the LCA process.
Goal
and scope definition
Proper
definition of goal and scope is important. Realize that it is a resource
demanding task to conduct a full LCA. In practice it is not always necessary to
conduct full LCAs. Sometimes you only need rough results. A limited LCA could be
relevant if the goal is to compare two construction materials in a specific
phase of a product development project. On the other hand, a comprehensive LCA
could be relevant if the result will be communicated to an external audience.
The
intended use of the results is important to consider in the goal and scope
definition phase. Common LCA applications in ABB are product development and
marketing. In product development projects LCA is used to identify significant
environmental aspects for defining sustainability objectives according to the
ABB Gate model. In marketing, LCA results are used to communicate environmental
benefits to customers through LCA based EPDs.
Inventory analysis
The
inventory phase is the most time consuming step of an LCA. The needed
inventory data are often difficult to retrieve since you need to involve various
actors in the supply chain, mostly outside your own company’s control. The
level of ambition to collect data "for every screw" could be a little
bit too high among LCA practitioners who are conducting their first LCAs. The
advice is to be realistic already in your goal and scope definition regarding
what inventory data that should be collected.
Even
if limiting system boundaries is difficult you should try to make a first
estimation of what materials, components and processes components to be included
in the LCA as early as possible in your study. You could make a first telephone
contact with potential data suppliers to check if it is expected that suppliers
could provide you with input data or not.
The
inventory data quality is difficult to handle in practice. Unfortunately there
are no commonly accepted numerical criteria available to easily assess the data
quality. The data quality requirements depend on the situation and application
where the data are used, why there are no “good” or no “bad” data in
absolute terms. Imagine two products containing polycarbonate. The first product
contains 50% polycarbonate and the second 3% polycarbonate. It is obvious that a
crude inventory data set for polycarbonate might be of enough quality for the
second product but probably not for the first. A practical advice to overcome
this is to conduct a first screening LCA to identify critical materials and
processes and then spend most time on retrieving inventory work for the critical
data sets.
Impact
assessment
Selection of impact assessment
method must be based on the studied system since this varies a lot between
different product systems. A common impact assessment method used in ABB is GWP,
Global Warming Potential, since ABB’s products are converting or transmitting
energy in one way or another.
You can evaluate the results on
different levels, for example:
- Life
cycle inventory analysis results in summarized inventory values in mass or
energy units, for example "The studied product releases 40.000 kg CO2
during its life cycle". This is an objective way to present the
results. It is however not easy to interpret the results without being an
expert in ecology.
- Characterization results in different
environmental impact categories. GWP, Global Warming Potential, and AP,
Acidification
Potential exemplifies two such categories. This way of
presenting the results is common and it is used in EPDs, Environmental
Product Declarations.
- Weighting
shows the results aggregated into one single number for each assessed
product. This is an optional part of an LCA and should always be used with
care.
Interpretation
of the results
The
last concluding part of an LCA study is to interpret the result in relation to
the intended audience. To do this you need to understand the intended
application. Since LCA is a complex tool there is a risk of confusing the users
with a very large amount of figures, tables and diagrams, that may all be
relevant but difficult to understand. A piece of advice is therefore to spend
enough time in structuring the report from a user perspective.
Business value
It is good business to understand the environmental impacts of your product
system since cost efficient improvement actions could then be taken and business
relevant information could be selected for use in market communication.
|